Tag Archives: criticism

1. Broken Social Scene: “7/4 ((Shoreline))”

For a pretty steadfast consumer of “indie” music, I really took my sweet time coming around on BSS. Part of the problem is the inherent flaws of this age of digital music consumption; my first impressions of the collective were colored by the fact that I was trying to gauge whether or not I liked them based on 30-second soundclips, and while this is generally enough time to hear at least one verse, chorus, and a handful of hooks in the average Britney Spears single, regardless of at what point in the song the clip starts at, this model doesn’t really work for a more free-form group of musicians like BSS. So I finally took the opportunity to give whole songs a listen a little over a year ago after being pleasantly surprised by head BSS-er Kevin Drew’s solo album Spirit If… in my local record shop. While roughly 50-70% of the tracks on all BSS albums proper are still a little too meandering and amelodic for my tastes, they do have a handful of gems, including this one.

2. The Jesus & Mary Chain: “Walk And Crawl”

This track is one of the b-sides/rarities recently compiled on the box set The Power of Negative Thinking. Beyond that, there’s not much else to say; it’s a JaMC track. Lots of feedback, a simple, undeniable melody, and some vaguely sinister lyrics about drugs/sex/violence, buzzing by in under three minutes.

3. Wilco: “Pot Kettle Black”

A deep cut from their famously rejected Yankee Hotel Foxtrot album. It’s pretty straightforward, and relatively no-frills…could be justifiably mistaken for a Summerteeth b-side, but with less pristine production. Reminds me of The Cure’s “In-Between Days” for some reason.

4. Kaiser Chiefs: “Everyday I Love You Less and Less”

One of the two strongest tracks off debut disc Employment (the other being “I Predict a Riot”.) Big comparisons made between these guys and Blur when this album came out. I can definitely see the similarity, but this is 100% artifice (not that Blur were particularly “authentic”) and sounds like a deep cut off Parklife or The Great Escape; it’s inherently catchier than anything off of Modern Life is Rubbish, if only because Blur had grown more accomplished at their craft, but still not close to the level of an iconic track like “The Universal” or “Girls & Boys”. As much as I’d like to believe Kaiser Chiefs have a classic album, or even classic single in them, I just don’t feel like they do.

5. The Smiths: “Stretch Out and Wait”

A very flimsy, tossed-off b-side that somehow is still better than 99.999% of anything anyone else has ever produced in pop. It’s a lighthearted exhortation to forget one’s cares, because the end is nigh, but it’s presented in such a sprightly package that it’s hard not to want to hop in a hammock with a cup of tea and wait for the bomb to drop.

6. My Bloody Valentine: “When You Sleep”

Probably the most “accessible” track off of the epic Loveless album. Somewhere, in an alternate universe, this is held in the same regard as “I Want to Hold Your Hand”.

7. The Walkmen: “Long Time Ahead of Us”

This year’s You & Me album was a pleasant surprise. It’s a return to form after the flat and tuneless A Hundred Miles Off. There’s a lot of quaint romanticism on this album, perfectly reflected in the art that graces the sleeve, depicting the false innocence of a by-gone age that we all know was never innocent at all, but that we can’t help but feel wistfully nostalgic for.

8. Husker Du: “Everything Falls Apart”

As much as I love this (and many other) Husker Du songs, all I can hear usually is the lack of discernible low-end. These guys were post-punk White Stripes before the White Stripes even existed, but they actually had a bass player!

9. The Meeting Places: “Turned Over”

One of those perpetually unfashionable “nu-gaze” bands that never seems able to expand their fanbase beyond people waiting around for that Slowdive reunion that will never come. It’s dreamy pop, with lots of layered, effect-laden guitars, but you can actually tell what’s being sung!

10. The National: “Slow Show”

A great song from an album chock full of them. Every time I listen to these guys, all I seem to focus on is the drumming. It’s just so integral to the success of The National’s tunes, not merely setting the pace, but really coloring and adding depth to what are seemingly simple songs. And of course, Matt Berninger’s voice is up there in the phone book pantheon*.

*Meaning, I’d listen to him sing the phone book without complaint. Others include Richard Hawley, Evan Dando, Mark Lanegan.

It’s almost 2009! That means every music magazine in existence either has already presented or is going to present their best-albums/songs-of-the-year lists in the coming weeks. I myself still have one or two last-minute purchases to make before I can comfortably assemble my own list. A lot of stuff came out this year, but I’m beginning to come around to the idea that the long-playing album is more or less dead. Meaning, it didn’t used to cause me a migraine to think of an album that wowed me from start to finish. No such luck this year. How these magazines can stretch out their lists to 20, 33, or even 50 (alternate) selections just baffles me. I buy way more than 10 albums every year, but I can truthfully say that there is rarely a 12 month period that produces more than 10 “classic” albums, and that number is most likely going to dwindle as we move forward into the iTunes age. I’m still something of a purist, prefering to use mp3s as a tool for discovering artists and albums that I may want to own an actual CD of. I like liner notes and sleeve art; I’m a graphic designer—sue me. But as quality long-player output continues to wane, I can already sense the impending, inevitable shift to a more digital musical diet. Progress! (Right?)

dischorddesoto: Dude, one of the music sites I go to had a Black Crowes discussion, and someone was asking a poster going to a show to “report back about how the new album sounds.”

dischorddesoto: It took all my willpower not to reply screaming at him to just listen to any other one of their albums at random.

popgirlsetc: Hahaha

dischorddesoto: I mean, seriously, people. That’s like me breathlessly asking what the new Oasis album will sound like.

dischorddesoto: LIKE FUCKING OASIS.

popgirlsetc: Dude, I totally agree that it was lame of Maxim to run that review, but it’s still hilarious. I’d have to say that that critic’s “educated guess” was more accurate than not.

dischorddesoto: Maxim is shit, but I wish they had just run with it and been like, “fuck them.” Sadly, I’d assume that much of their readership LOVES the Black Crowes.

popgirlsetc: Did I ever tell you about my friend Steven’s run-in with Liam?

dischorddesoto: Nah, when?

popgirlsetc: A few months before Stop The Clocks came out.

dischorddesoto: Was alcohol involved?

popgirlsetc: I dunno. It was at like 10am. But it was Liam…

popgirlsetc: Anyway, Steven was in London on business, and checking out of the same hotel Liam was checking into with his lady and their kids. Steven’s like Oasis super-fan #99, and goes up to Liam and just says, “Hey Liam, I just want to say what a huge fan I am, and how excited I am for Stop The Clocks to come out.”

popgirlsetc: Liam just smirks and replies, “Well, I’m sure it won’t be anything we haven’t heard before.”

dischorddesoto: Oh, that sassy devil. And I’m sure it was much less coherent.

popgirlsetc: And more combative.

dischorddesoto: HAHAHAHA!

popgirlsetc: And homophobic in a veiled way.

dischorddesoto: Of course. And with the term “god-like” thrown in.