Tag Archives: AFC

We didn't sell out—we bought in!

We didn't sell out—we bought in!

Before I get into why I like this logo so much, let’s let the internet take credit where it’s due:

From Wikipedia:

The Steelers logo was introduced in 1962 and is based on the “Steelmark,” originally designed by Pittsburgh’s U.S. Steel and now owned by the American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI). In fact, it was Cleveland-based Republic Steel that suggested the Steelers adopt the industry logo. It consists of the word “Steelers” surrounded by three astroids (hypocycloids of four cusps). The original meanings behind the astroids were, “Steel lightens your work, brightens your leisure, and widens your world.” Later, the colors came to represent the ingredients used in the steel-making process: yellow for coal, orange for iron ore, and blue for scrap steel.[24] While the formal Steelmark logo contains only the word “Steel,” the team was given permission to add “ers” in 1963 after a petition to AISI.

The Steelers are the only NFL team that puts its logo on only one side of the helmet (the right side). Longtime field and equipment manager Jack Hart was instructed to do this by Art Rooney as a test to see how the logo appeared on the gold helmets; however, its popularity led the team to leave it that way permanently.

I don’t know why, but I’ve always found that to be a cool story that demonstrates the sort of communal spirit that athletic teams generate, even if it was clearly a case on both sides of trying to align their respective identities with a perceived winner.

In any event, what I like about the Steelers’ logo is the anomalous use of color. What I mean by that is they use the red and blue sparingly, only appearing as accents within the context of the logo itself. They don’t otherwise appear as part of the uniform, which is consistently black and yellow. It actually gives the red and blue more visual weight by using them less. This is further emphasized by the logo only appearing on the right side of the helmet—the fact that it only appears on the one side throws the helmet off-kilter, but not in a bad way. It just makes you notice it more, and remember it longer, and seek out the reasons behind  the decision (not the easiest thing to do when the information super-highway is just a twinkle in a nerd’s eye when you’re a little kid.)

Another aspect of the Steelers’ logo that I find very cool is the abstract symbolism of the astroids in the logo. They aren’t explicitly representational of the things they symbolize, which lends it an air of mystery. I remember thinking when I was growing up that the “stars” each represented one of the three rivers that intersected near the shores of downtown Pittsburgh, the Monongahela, the Allegheny, and the Ohio. It was a logical assumption, though incorrect. That being said, the cool thing about abstract symbolism is that it allows for such interpretations.

Oilers' derrick

Oilers' derrick

Oilers’ Derrick

This was another “grower”, as I didn’t really appreciate this logo until it became obsolete when the Oilers changed over to the Titans. As averse as I am philosophically to the championing of non-renewable fossil fuels, there’s powerful iconography at play here, completely “American” in both its selection and its perceived importance. The red, white and blue imagery is obvious in meaning, but what’s really telling about our attitudes as citizens is the uncompromising pride this kind of logo evoked. At this point in history, with so much being said about converting the American economy base back to one of production from one of consumption, the spirit of the mark is accurate (when it hadn’t been for almost 25 years), but the paradigm shift from fossil fuels to green energy is totally at odds with what the oil derrick represents.

So as unfortunate as it is that such a great, meaningful logo had to fall by the wayside, it makes a ton of sense as a reflection of the cultural shift our country is currently undergoing. Give it another 10-15 years, and this little red, white and blue oil derrick will take on a quaintness no one would have ever associated with something football-related. And that’s kind of cool.

Shocker of shockers, in addition to being an avid consumer of pop music, I’m also a big sports fan (I had a hip coworker look at me quizzically one day when she saw me wearing a Washington Redskins football jersey the day after I was seen sporting a Joy Division tee). And a graphic designer with a passion for great logos and brand marks. So interspersed among our usual content, I’m going to be counting down my Top 10 favorite logos of the major professional sports leagues. Since we’re in the thick of the NFL season, and with an entire day of Turkey Day football right around the corner, let’s jump right in, shall we?

No. 10, Tennessee Titans

Thumbtacks!

Thumbtacks!

Titans’ “thumbtack” logo

As a rule, I tend to hate expansion teams. Or rather, expansion teams chartered since I became sports-aware. They mess up divisional and conference affiliations, and tend to have very “of-the-moment” uniform and logo designs that look dated within about five to ten years.

To be fair, the Titans were not an expansion team; they represented the reinvention of the former Houston Oilers after they relocated to Nashville in the late 1990s. This logo was something of a grower; I hated it for a very long time. I wasn’t a fan of the light blue, and the design itself smacked of some lower-tier league, like the CFL or a European football team. But I’ve slowly come around, appreciating the thought that went into the design. The three stars representing the Tennessee state flag, the “t” with the star placed above it a stylized representation of a torch (in Greek mythology, Prometheus was the Titan that dared to bring fire down from the gods to give to man), which is further reinforced by the flame trailing behind it. The light blue is a clear reference back to the team’s history in Houston, which escaped me at the time of the logo’s introduction, but now seems honorable and worthy of appreciation. All in all, a fine logo for a team that looks poised to represent the AFC in the 2009 playoffs.